Skip to content
Fun updates + birthday perks (like 20% off!) 🎉 Sign up to join the party!
Fun updates + birthday perks (like 20% off!) 🎉 Sign up to join the party!

TASTY TREATS

For those who prefer experiences over clutter, food is always a thoughtful gift—because everyone loves a little treat. We just refreshed our pantry section with favorite specialty foods, from cocktail mixers for easy drinks and mocktails to local Iveta scone mixes made right here in Santa Cruz, perfect with fruity jams and tea. For something sweet, browse biscuit cookies, creamy caramels, chocolate bars with clever flavor combinations, honey, hot sauce, and classic Marini’s favorites like handmade chocolates, seafoam, toffee, chocolate caramels, and salt water taffy. From cozy breakfast pairings to little bites of happiness, these are gifts made to be enjoyed.

  • compartes chocolatier Margarita on the rocks
    compartes chocolatier campfire smores
    $ 13.75
    Compartes Chocolate

    Compartés Assorted Dark Chocolate Bars

    Crafted with passion in the heart of Los Angeles, Compartés Chocolatier delivers an irresistible taste experience that'll have you reaching for mor...

    View full details
    $ 13.75
  • scone mix
    Lavender chocolate scone mix
    $ 13.95
    Ivéta

    Assorted Scone Mixes

    Bake delicious scones easily with our local scone mixes by Iveta! Each package makes 8 tasty scones in flavors like Blueberry, Cranberry Orange, La...

    View full details
    $ 13.95
  • Compartés Chocolatier Assorted Milk Chocolate Bars presented in an elegant black box with gold snowflake design, featuring a sticky toffee milk chocolate bar being revealed. Handmade in Los Angeles, these chocolates offer a delicious treat perfect for gifting.
    compartes chocolatier coney island
    $ 13.75
    Compartes Chocolate

    Compartés Chocolatier Assorted Milk Chocolate Bars

    Compartés Chocolatier is so good, you won't be able to get enough! Handmade in Los Angeles chocolate kitchens.

    $ 13.75
  • compartes chocolatier matcha green tea
    compartes chocolatier strawberry shortcake
    $ 13.75
    Compartes Chocolate

    Compartés Chocolatier Assorted White Chocolate Bars

    Crafted with care in our Los Angeles chocolate studios, Compartés Chocolatier delivers the kind of indulgence that keeps you coming back for more. ...

    View full details
    $ 13.75
  • Makabi & Sons butter cookies
    Makabi & Sons butter cookies
    $ 9.75
    Makabi & Sons

    Makabi & Sons Assorted Cookies

      Discover Makabi & Sons Assorted Cookies, each a buttery shortbread with a unique twist. From spicy chocolate cinnamon cayenne to floral laven...

    View full details
    $ 9.75
  • Big heart tea blushing pink hibiscus tea
    Big Heart Tea Co. Teas Assorted Flavors
    $ 14.50
    Big Heart Tea Co.

    Big Heart Tea Co. Teas | Assorted Flavors

    Discover Big Heart Tea Co.'s assorted flavors, each in extra-large compostable bags that let the tea fully bloom. From the calming Cozy Night chamo...

    View full details
    $ 14.50
  • Poppy Popcorn Dill Pickle
    Poppy Popcorn Dill Pickle
    from $ 7.95
    Poppy Hand-Crafted Popcorn

    Poppy Popcorn

    Joy in Every Kernel Get ready to pop your snack game to the next level with Poppy Popcorn! Founded by popcorn enthusiast Ginger Frank in 2014, ...

    View full details
    from $ 7.95
  • Bear Claw Made by Spokandy Chocolatier
    Two chocolate treats from Spokandy Chocolatier, featuring a Bigfoot Paw in milk chocolate with almonds and a Black Bear Claw in dark chocolate, elegantly displayed on a wooden log background, embodying the playful indulgence of Paw & Claw Chocolate.
    $ 8.95
    Spokandy Chocolatier

    Paw & Claw Chocolate

    Crafted by the artisans at Spokandy Chocolatier, these woodsy treats feature your choice of Black Bear Claws or Bigfoot Paws—each one a delightful ...

    View full details
    $ 8.95
  • lavender honey
    California Honey
    $ 24.00
    Bonny Doon Farm

    Bonny Doon Infused Honey

    Unfiltered and local, this Lavender Infused Honey from Bonny Doon Farm brings the best of California straight to your kitchen. Infused with delicat...

    View full details
    $ 24.00
  • vegan jalapeno garlic hot sauce
    gluten free hot sauce
    $ 11.95
    Oso Rojo Hot Sauce

    Oso Rojo Hot Sauce | Assorted Flavors

    Forget the myth that heat has to steal the show—Oso Rojo Hot Sauce puts flavor front and center. Born in Denver from chef Cameron Ayers' passion fo...

    View full details
    $ 11.95
  • Ekone smoked oysters
    Ekone from tide to tin smoked oysters
    $ 16.50
    Ekone

    Ekone Canned Smoked Oysters

    Grown on our farms in Willapa Bay, located on the coast of Washington State, they are grown using the long-line method to promote the highest quali...

    View full details
    $ 16.50
  • Seattle Chocolates Maeve Truffle Bars - Assorted Flavors with a delightful Hungry Blackberry filling, featuring rich dark chocolate and organic blackberry powder.
    Seattle Chocolates Maeve Truffle Bars - Assorted Flavors showcasing the fun and eco-conscious brand with delicious Cabin S'mores flavor in meltaway milk chocolate.
    $ 7.75
    Seattle Chocolate Presents Maeve

    Seattle Chocolates Maeve Truffle Bars | Assorted Flavors

    When you pick Maeve, you’re choosing a sustainably sourced, eco-conscious, woman-owned brand — and you’re also choosing fun. • Woman-owned and led•...

    View full details
    $ 7.75
  • Mouthwatering milk chocolate caramel pecan candies by Marini's Handmade Chocolates & Candies, featuring rich creamy caramel and crunchy pecans, topped with a touch of sea salt.
    Delicious dark chocolate caramel pecan candies by Marini's Handmade Chocolates & Candies, showcasing layers of creamy caramel and crunchy pecans, with a sprinkling of sea salt.
    $ 10.00
    Marini's

    Marini’s Handmade Chocolates & Candies | Toffee

    A beloved Santa Cruz tradition returns to downtown! Since 1915, four generations of Marini’s Candies have been handcrafting sweet memories on the S...

    View full details
    $ 10.00
  • Meadowland simple syrup salted honey cardamom
    Meadowland simple syrup passion fruit & hibiscus
    $ 19.95
    Meadowland Syrup

    Meadowland Simple Syrups

    These handcrafted simple syrups from Oregon are the perfect playful twist for your green tea or gin cocktails! Non-GMO and free from artificial col...

    View full details
    $ 19.95
  • Close-up of Sour Peach Fish - Swedish Candy 5.2oz (150g) highlighting the peach and apricot flavors in a delicious gummy treat.
    Sour Peach Fish - Swedish Candy 5.2oz (150g) pack showcasing vibrant gummy candies inspired by peach cobbler, vegan and gluten-free.
    $ 8.99
    Sweetish

    Sour Peach Fish

    The second member in our family of fish is the sour peach! With this flavor we set out to create a peach dominant gummy with a medium-chew, complem...

    View full details
    $ 8.99
  • Marini's Handmade Chocolates & Candies presenting stacks of chocolate-covered caramel pecan bars, blending crunchy and creamy textures in each bite.
    $ 10.00
    Marini's

    Marini’s Handmade Chocolates & Candies | Pecan Patties

    A beloved Santa Cruz tradition returns to downtown! Since 1915, four generations of Marini’s Candies have been handcrafting sweet memories on the S...

    View full details
    $ 10.00
  • Close-up view of Sour Blackberry Fish - Swedish Candy featuring deliciously colorful and sour gummy fish, perfect for sweets lovers.
    Sour Blackberry Fish - Swedish Candy 5.2oz (150g) package showcasing vibrant sour gummy fish candies that are vegan and gluten-free.
    $ 8.99
    Sweetish

    Sour Blackberry Fish

    Our Sour Blackberry Fish candy is a commemoration of the homemade jam we used to make with freshly picked blackberries from our summer gardens in S...

    View full details
    $ 8.99
  • Close-up of Sour Elderflower Fish - Swedish Candy 5.2oz (150g) highlighting the unique sour flavor and vibrant color that brings a taste of Sweden.
    Sour Elderflower Fish - Swedish Candy 5.2oz (150g) packaging showcasing vegan and gluten-free ingredients with a nostalgic summer theme.
    $ 8.99
    Sweetish

    Sour Elderflower Fish

    Our Sour Elderflower Fish are a tribute to the homemade cordial that was made from freshly picked flowers by our grandparents, during Sweden’s shor...

    View full details
    $ 8.99
  • Moomin Sour Gummies featuring adorable Moomin characters, bursting with vibrant flavors like lemon, raspberry, cola, and melon, ready to tickle your taste buds with their refined sour punch!
    $ 6.99
    Sweetish

    Moomin Sour Gummies

    Shaped like beloved Moomin characters, these playful sour gummies feature a bright mix of flavors, including lemon, raspberry, cola, and melon. The...

    View full details
    $ 6.99
  • Dive deep into the delicious Sour Wild Strawberry Fish, the perfect gummy catch for Easter baskets that won't wriggle away!
    Sour Wild Strawberry Fish - the only fish that won't swim away, packed with a sweet and sour flavor that sweetens Valentine's Day!
    $ 8.99
    Sweetish

    Sour Wild Strawberry Fish

    We spent 18 months of research and development to create, what is to our minds, the best gummy every produced. The Sour wild strawberry fish is a v...

    View full details
    $ 8.99
  • Delicious Halvatini Spread by First Friday, a reimagined Middle Eastern halva that's spreadable, delicate, and naturally sweetened.
    from $ 12.00
    *First Friday

    Halvatini Spread

    A reimagined take on the classic Middle Eastern halva, spreadable, delicate, and naturally sweetened. Every spoonful celebrates the art of simplici...

    View full details
    from $ 12.00
  • Chocatini - A luscious blend of cacao and creamy sesame, this plant-based indulgence is rich and pure, perfect for those seeking depth without compromise.
    from $ 12.00
    *First Friday

    Chocatini

    A luscious blend of cacao and creamy sesame. Plant-based indulgence with depth and purity. Crafted for those who crave richness without compromise....

    View full details
    from $ 12.00
  • Carob Syrup by First Friday, a golden syrup made from premium carob pods, ideal for drizzling, baking, or blending in your favorite recipes.
    from $ 12.00
    *First Friday

    Carob Syrup

    A golden syrup crafted from premium carob pods. Naturally sweet, low glycemic, and nutrient-dense. This caffeine-free sweetener is a natural source...

    View full details
    from $ 12.00
  • Carobini: A wholesome fusion of carob and tahini, featuring a smooth, balanced blend of nutty sesame and sweet carob.
    from $ 12.00
    *First Friday

    Carobini

    A wholesome fusion of carob and tahini. Where nutty sesame meets the gentle sweetness of carob. Smooth, balanced, and deeply satisfying, a fusion b...

    View full details
    from $ 12.00
  • Delicious Olallieberry Jam from Small Batch Jam Co. showcasing its rich, dark color and lightly seeded texture - perfect for making your toast jealous!
    Mouthwatering Olallieberry Jam spilling from a jar, promising a sweet adventure that's berry good and totally spreadable!
    $ 17.95
    Small Batch Jam Co.

    Olallieberry Jam

    Olallieberries are a true California gem—originally developed in Oregon as a cross between a blackberry and a youngberry, and released in 1950. The...

    View full details
    $ 17.95
  • Close-up of Mulberry Jam, showcasing the rich texture and lightly seeded goodness that demands a spoon to enjoy like a true jam connoisseur.
    A jar of Mulberry Jam from Small Batch Jam Co. looking radiant and ready to jazz up your breakfast like a berry superstar.
    $ 14.25
    Small Batch Jam Co.

    Mulberry Jam

    Sweet, earthy, and deeply flavorful, Mulberries have a rich quality that makes them stand out from your typical berry. This jam is lightly seeded f...

    View full details
    $ 14.25
  • Spoonful of Raspberry Jam overflowing with flavor, a perfect match for dessert or a cheeky glaze - it’s jam-tastic!
    Raspberry Jam in a jar, ready to elevate your PB&J game to gourmet levels - who knew berries could be this delightful?
    $ 14.25
    Small Batch Jam Co.

    Raspberry Jam

    After the success of our Raspberry Jalapeño Jam, we figured it was time to give raspberries their own solo moment. And wow—are we glad we did. This...

    View full details
    $ 14.25
  • Smooth and creamy Tahini made from finely ground sesame seeds, perfect for enhancing sweet and savory dishes.
    from $ 12.00
    *First Friday

    Tahini

    Tahini is a smooth paste made from finely ground sesame seeds. With its rich, nutty flavor and creamy texture, it’s a versatile staple for both swe...

    View full details
    from $ 12.00
  • Sizzling serving of Kelp Chili Crisp 6 oz jar, giving your food a crunchy, classy kick without breaking a sweat.
    Kelp Chili Crisp 6 oz jar ready to elevate your dish game with crunchy umami goodness and spicy vibes.
    $ 16.95
    Barnacle Foods

    Kelp Chili Crisp (6 oz)

    All Products Ship FREE. See why Kelp Chili Crisp is in the top 1% for reordered condiments on Faire! Kelp Chili Crisp is a savory, crunchy condimen...

    View full details
    $ 16.95
  • Natural Strawberry Jam showcasing its vibrant color and texture, ready to spread a little happiness on toast or biscuits.
    Delicious Strawberry Jam from Small Batch Jam Co., made with fresh-picked strawberries, perfect for PB&J cravings and sneaky spoonfuls.
    $ 14.25
    Small Batch Jam Co.

    Strawberry Jam

    With fresh-picked strawberries showing up all over the Bay Area starting in May—from farmers markets to roadside stands—it was a no-brainer for us ...

    View full details
    $ 14.25
  • Get twisted with Sweetish's Licorice Twist - a cheeky treat that's savory-sweet and takes your taste buds on a rollercoaster ride of flavor!
    Licorice Twist from Sweetish - a scrumptious blend of chewy black licorice that dances between sweet and salty, perfect for the adventurous candy lover!
    $ 8.99
    Sweetish

    Licorice Twist

    BonBon’s new Salty Licorice Twists pay homage to the cultural heritage of BonBon and their lifelong love for this unique candy. In Sweden, salty ca...

    View full details
    $ 8.99
  • Marini's Handmade Chocolates & Candies highlighting a close-up of chocolate-dipped honeycomb bars showcasing their airy, crispy texture.
    Marini's Handmade Chocolates & Candies displaying rich honeycomb treats dipped in dark chocolate, offering a crispy, sweet delight.
    Sold out
    $ 10.00
    Marini's

    Marini’s Handmade Chocolates & Candies | Seafoam

    A beloved Santa Cruz tradition returns to downtown! Since 1915, four generations of Marini’s Candies have been handcrafting sweet memories on the S...

    View full details
    $ 10.00